As you may recall, a couple weeks ago, I posted a link to a New York Times column in which the author lambasted the new Manhattan JC Penney for its polyblends and larger size selection. I also posted a lovely comeback piece from Jezebel...
Well a lot of you had your own feedback!
"Wow. That's the most awful thing I have ever read... I hope that people don't read that and think that's what NY is. It isn't - the new JCP has been packed since it opened and not all with tourists. With real New Yorkers looking for clothes that fit real people..."
"NY Times alienating even more readers?! No surprise there, I guess. No wonder the written word newspaper is going out of business. Can't wait for their next article entitled 'Isn't it cute that women have important jobs?'"
"I can't imagine a professional talking crap about such a huge population of people. It sure doesn't sound like she values ALL of her readers. I hope the feedback was so horrible that she was reprimanded."
Well, speaking of reprimanded...
The NY Times Goes After Its Own Cintra Wilson
It's been a week and a half since the NY Times published a bitchy review of Manhattan's first J.C. Penney, penned by columnist Cintra Wilson (pictured). She received plenty of unkind words in return for her barrage of insults about the average American woman and her size 12 style. Last week, she declared on her blog that the issue has been "flame-broiled to death" (a nod to the fast food nation she targeted?), but yesterday the Gray Lady gave her a lexical slap on the wrist.
In the piece, Bill Keller, executive editor of The Times, says his mother was a Penney's devotee, and goes on to publicly declare that he wishes Wilson's review was never published, saying it “would make a fine exhibit for someone making the case that The Times has an arrogant streak." Yet they go on to say the real surprise is "that Wilson’s reviews haven’t created more of a controversy before now.“ As the writer herself explains, her biting style is meant for who she believes her audience to be: “1,300 women in Connecticut and urban gay guys in Manhattan.”
Meanwhile, the department store's VP of Communications told the paper, “We found the review very offensive to our customers.” She went on to say that the average American woman wears a size 12 and weighs 150 lbs; while the shop was stocked for their regular customers, in Manhattan "smaller sizes sold out quickly, and the mix will be adjusted to meet demand." But even if more size 2 products are on the racks, will Wilson dare let Penney's polyblend graze her skin?
source: http://gothamist.com/2009/08/24/the_ny_times_goes_after_its_own_cin.php
And thanks to Steph for sending that to me. It made me smile with satisfaction and vindication.











